Killer Prose Podcast
Killer Prose Podcast
Killer Prose is the podcast dedicated to the art and business of crime and thriller writing. Hosted by private investigator turned crime writer, Tanner Rutledge, Killer Prose brings fifteen years of investigative experience to the page. Join Tanner as he discusses real-world cases and how they translate to the page to create compelling detectives and cases that readers can connect with.
Nov. 20, 2026

Make Your Crime Fiction Hit Harder: Line and Copy Editing

Make Your Crime Fiction Hit Harder: Line and Copy Editing
Make Your Crime Fiction Hit Harder: Line and Copy Editing
Killer Prose Podcast
Make Your Crime Fiction Hit Harder: Line and Copy Editing

In today’s episode, I break down my process for line and copy editing in my crime fiction novels and how my detective’s insights and personality shape the world my readers experience.

I don’t get into the tools I use, but if you are wondering, I use both Autocrit and ProWritingAid. I’ve found that both have unique strengths that help me dot all my Is and cross my Ts.

Takeaways:

  • I distinguish copy editing from line editing and perform copy edits before line edits.
  • I set the tone and choice of words so the scene reflects character perspective and genre expectations.
  • I manage the order of observations, pacing, and information release to prevent disruptive info dumps and preserve narrative tension.
  • I refine dialogue to remove clichés, establish distinct voices, and cultivate authentic chemistry between characters.
  • To avoid breaking my story, I create reverse outlines using note cards or software to track continuity, character arcs, and plot coherence across scenes.

Companies mentioned in this episode:

Some links you see here are affiliate links. If you decide to make a purchase a small portion of the sale goes to the Killer Prose Podcast:

Connect with the show at:

00:00 - Untitled

00:28 - Line & Copy Editing: Polishing Crime and Detective Stories

03:18 - Copy Edits: Order of Operations

08:50 - Dialogue: Avoiding Clichés and Shaping Character Voice

10:53 - Polishing Your Prose: Read-Throughs and Line Edits

13:14 - Developmental Editing — Focusing on Plot and the Case

Tanner Rutledge

On this episode of the Killer Pros podcast, I'm talking about the part of the process that really brings the magic into your work.It fills out the scenes, it makes sure that the logic flows in a way that is understandable to your reader, that makes sense and is realistic.And it's where a lot of the personality and chemistry comes from between your characters with their dialogue and the way that they are experiencing and interacting with their world.I'm talking about the line and copy edits in your crime fiction and detective stories on today's episode.Let's go ahead and get into it.Welcome back to the Killer Pros Podcast.I'm your host, Tanner, and today we're talking about line and copy edits.That is the spot that I'm at right now as I'm working through Dangerous Whispers.I'm making sure everything looks good and the, the writing, the prose are tight and the story flows in a way that the readers are really going to enjoy.This is also where I set it into the tone and, and the, the subcategory of mystery that it's going to fit by how characters are interacting with each other, the language that's used, and that's a really important part of genre fiction because this is actually where a lot of the reader expectations come in.So I finished the developmental edits, all of the structural stuff so the story beats themselves.That people reading a soft boiled small town mystery are going to expect are in the book.We've got the unique little town.We have the finding of the body, the reluctant detective taking the case and, and then working through the case with the red herrings and the twists and turns you would expect in a fair play puzzle mystery.Along with some cues for dialogue, character development and higher stakes violence that pushes the book out of cozy and into the soft boiled mystery category.Now I am on line and copy, or I should say copy and line because I do the copy edit first, the line edit second, and yes, those are different things.When I'm doing a copy edit, I'm going through, I'm looking at readability, I'm looking at how the scene itself unfolds, quality of the prose and the reader's journey through the scene.And then with line edits, I'm really looking more for grammatical errors or if I've tried something that maybe necessarily didn't work, maybe I have too complex of a sentence that is slowing the reading down too much and it's taking the pace away.That's really the stuff that I'm looking for in line.Edits, line edits basically sharpen and strengthen the writing at the sentence level.Copy edits, strengthen the writing at the scene or larger picture level, but not quite total large picture.Well, you know what?Let's get into it.When I sit down to start my copy edits, I go through a list or an order of operations.The first thing that I'm looking at in the scene is the tone.What type of tone do I want?Is this a little darker or creepier?You all want to make sure that there's some humor in there.What promise, especially this early in the book, am I making to my reader?The scene that I just finished going through and doing my copy and line edits was the scene where my detective found the body and was starting to reluctantly investigate the scene.So when I opened it up, I looked at the tone.What's the character feeling?How is that going to color the observations?And through the tone, what.What colors are my readers seeing when they're reading the scene?And I don't mean putting in reds or blues.I mean emotionally, how do we paint that scene?Word choice plays a big part of that.And also how the character is walking around the scene plays a huge part.Part in that.After I make sure the tone is where it needs to be for that scene in the rest of the book, I go into flow as the reader is experiencing the scene.How do things unfold specifically with the detective?I'm looking at the order of observations.When I was an investigator, I was taught to work scenes a very particular way.You start with the event site or the catalyst.In this particular scene, it would be the dead body.Then you kind of noddle a shell or you open the radius of a circle up as you walk through the scene, seeing more and more of the room.And since we've already seen the room in the last chapter where the body was actually found, we're seeing more of the fine detail of the room as far as how it pertains to this, this particular case and pieces of evidence that my detective is going to cue in on.So the first things we're going to notice are little things about the body.And then we're going to move out from the body, seeing possibly signs of struggle missing from the room.Little things that a good professional, well, amateur detective with some professional training are going to see and want to make sure that that order is followed.From there, I'm going to look at the pros and the pacing.Now, this is a close third.If.If you're doing a third, if you're doing any sort of close pov, first person or close third.Those are pretty much the only two that I use.You want to make sure that you are coloring the word choice through the investigator.So the voice of the narrator is going to track pretty close to the character that's being observed.And you want to use a vernacular that that investigator would have.That can be a little strange, especially in the first draft.So this, when we're doing the copy edit, is really where I paint that.Where are they going to notice that a stool was tipped over?How observant is your detective at the first part of the mystery?And you're going to use that as your guiding rod and focus to guide the reader through what the scene actually looks like.Which brings me to the next part of the copy edit, which is the pacing and the pros, specifically, because that's a big way you're going to control the pace.When we are investigating a room, it's slow and kind of methodical, and the writing style should reflect that.So we have longer, I don't want to say rambling, but maybe sprawling sentences, a lot of deep thought for your characters.They're processing what they're seeing.You might want to withhold some of that for the reader.So as you're going back through and rereading, you might take some things out of that, but your character is processing the scene, and so it should be a little bit more rambling.I'm also looking for info dumps.One part in particular, I had an info dump in that chapter which described how my detective knew the chief.And I completely got rid of that paragraph because it broke up the prose and the pacing.I had a very nice guiding cadence through the investigative part of the scene.I had a nice ramp up in tension and shortening the sentences, getting a bit more punchy with the dialogue and more sparse with action movements.When the police first showed up to show some sort of tension there in the room.And then when the chief showed up, I wanted to show how the characters felt about each other, how they interacted with each other.That hinted to the massive info dump that I had right there that really broke the pace of the story.And I was able to do that in the actual description of the character because, remember, I am shining the light through my detective's lens.So the description that I used for the chief of police is what actually colored and gave hints to my readers about the past relationship and the history there between those two characters.So when you have those info dumps and you have that break in pacing, sometimes that information does need to be in the scene, or some of it needs to be in the scene, and the rest needs to be brought to light later.But you can do that through the actual way your detective or your character is describing someone else or something else.From there, I move into dialogue.I'm looking at cliches in my writing.Yours is going to be a little different.But in my writing, when I have cliches pop up, it is usually in dialogue.And I put it there as a placeholder when I'm writing the first draft so that I can get through the story as quickly as possible and then go back and fix it with something sharper, tighter, more unique.So first thing I'm looking for, there are cliches.I'm also looking at the character voices.I. I'm an audiobook narrator.I am a voice actor.So individual voice for characters is something that's very important to.To me.So I want to make sure that they sound different and they read different.I am using a different cadence with their speech.Maybe it's.Maybe it's a bit p. Maybe it's faster.Maybe it's more articulate for some characters.Maybe I am using a couple of little cues to show a southern draw or some other type of accent, and I want to make sure their voice comes through.And again, this is the same thing as the narrator voice that you're using for your detective.You want to look at your character that's speaking, know a little bit about their background, know a little bit about them, and then bring that dialogue through their point of view for this story so that it sounds different.Kate, very professional, honestly, snappy, kind of smartass.She's a fun police chief to write.Ted is a little damaged, and he notices a lot of things.He doesn't want to let a lot of stuff go.So when he talks, it is usually pretty sparse.Most of his dialogue is internal thought and dialogue as we go through the scene.But putting them together, I also want to make sure that there's good chemistry between him, the police officer that he's talking to, that shows some of the background animosity there between him and Kate to show some of their backgrounds.I'm doing a lot of these things at the same time.So when I'm doing the dialogue, I look at the cliches, the voice, the chemistry between the characters, and a lot of those are being taken care of at the same time on the pass through.And then when I'm finished with that, I do a read through to make sure everything is flowing correctly.I have a good logical order of events when it comes to hand placement, when it comes to somebody holding something in the right hand and then suddenly it not being there, looking for continuity errors.And I go through, I fix those, I get it tight, and then it's time for the line edit.And the line edit literally goes line by line.I read the sentences, I read them out loud.I have the computer read them to me sometimes through an automated voice.And I look for stuff that just doesn't sound right or feel right.Usually that's gonna happen in my slower places where maybe, okay, I've got too many commas.This sentence is too complex.It is slowing readers down too much and could take them out of the story.And so I might split that into a couple sentences or find another way to describe what I'm describing there.I also look at word choice.Do I have a whole lot of adverbs here or adjectives here?Is there a better word that I can put into this that's going to convey the emotion, convey the description that I am trying to get?And that comes out in the line edit.Really it is just sharpening the prose and making sure that there are no grammatical errors.Once that's done, the only thing that's left is a final proof and then that scene is done.Now, when I'm going through this stage, I write down what's happening in the scene, everything that's relative to the story.I write it on a brand new note card and I stick it up on my cork board in my writing studio.You might do that inside of Scrivener in the note card part.Or you might do that inside of a platform called plottr.Any way you do it, this is just a different way to get a reverse outline done so that you can see if it's tracking along with your original outline, where things have changed.And, you know, developmentally, is there something that you missed with a character arc or another part of the story?Because mysteries in particular, especially the type of mysteries I like to write soft boiled character driven mysteries and crime novels, they're very complex.It's probably one of the most complex stories or plots that you can write.So I want to make sure that's going and, you know, just a little thing that I want to throw on here at the end.The developmental edit, first and foremost looks at the plot and the plot of a crime novel is going to be the case.The story of the novel, which is what really hooks readers and brings them into Your world.The story is the characters, what is their journey?What is their internal journey?What do the relationships look like through the story and at the end of the story?That's hard to do in mystery.We're already trying to build, especially if you're doing a whodunit that has fair play rules.It's one of the hardest plots to write and execute properly.It's hard to do it in a linear fashion.I actually do nonlinear writing.I have a little bit of time jumping around in my stories.It is definitely hard to make that work in a mystery.But adding in the complexity of having this be a character driven story, which I think all stories should be, it's hard.So when you're doing your developmental edits, I usually go through two rounds of development.I make sure the plot and the case is where it needs to be and then I make sure the character arcs are where they need to be.So that when I'm going through and I'm doing my copy and my line edits, I can really focus on the prose and I can focus on the scene level dynamics to make sure that whatever's happening with those characters gets taken care of.It's what brings the magic into the story.It's what really sets the mood and brings that beautiful detail.Now, as I continue to go through this, something that I'm doing is beefing up my side characters and the the nutty people inside of the town of Whisper Hollow to make this something that is very special for the readers and a town and a setting that they're going to want to come back to regardless of whatever case is being worked.Again, that's all part of the story and we're going to be talking about that on future episodes of the podcast.Thanks for listening.If you have questions about how I'm doing things or what I'm using, you can reach out to me.Head over to killerpros.com contact.You can fill out a form, send in a question, or you can use that little voicemail feature.It's on the side of all of the pages.It says ask me a question.So moving forward, this is the most complex part of writing a novel for me, other than actually drafting the actual mystery and the plot.So over the next couple weeks, I am going to be very busy getting this finished so I can get the book out.I don't expect there to be another episode until December and I'll be talking specifically about writing amateur detectives, so keep an eye out for that every Thursday night at 10:30pm Eastern.I will be doing live writing sprints on our Twitch and YouTube channels.I'll link to that down in the show notes.Make sure you tune in for that.And yeah, I'm working my butt off to get this novel out so that you can actually see what I'm talking about in practice.So that's my take on lining copy.Thank you so much for joining me.Until next time, enjoy the process.

Ask a Question